Christian missionaries often led the way, followed by politicians, troops, andbringing up the rearbusinessmen. Long-standing personifications and visual symbols for countries were used by cartoonists to dramatize events to suit their message. In the West, China was often characterized as befuddled and archaic under the rule of an inscrutable crone, the Empress Dowager. Competency (trait) perspective. The conspicuously larger size of Britannias big guns inPucks cartoon reflects Englands leading role in imperial conquest. Copy of White Man's Burden Analysis.pdf - Perspectives on the White Mans Burden Directions: In 1899, British poet Rudyard Kipling wrote The White | Course Hero. That dragon must be killed before our troubles can be adjusted. 18, No. Esherick, Joseph. The message suggests that the indigenous man will be brought out of ignorance through the inescapable march of progress in the form of Western civilization. The turn-of-the-century visual record tells us otherwise. and Distributor, 2004). The graphics include pillage, rape, and wanton executions. Here the Auto-Truck of Civilization and Trade shines a headlight upon a raging dragon and sword-wielding Chinese Boxer whose banner reads 400 Million Barbarians. In the imagery of the civilizing mission, China is portrayed as both backward and savage. The scene above turns the tables on theHarpers Weeklycover (above) and accuses foreign troops and missionaries of atrocities during the Boxer Uprising in China. Source: Houghton Library, Harvard University. GlobalResearch Center for Research on Globalization. Death to all Schools but Ours. The last marcher holds up Drummers Samples, referring to the traveling salesmen of business and commerce. Japan is introduced in this 1899 cartoon as the lone Asian nation in the imperialist circle of world powers. Following its victory over China in the Sino-Japanese War of 1894-95, Japan had the heady experience of being welcomed into the imperialist circle. [Read Online], Vaughan, Christopher. Transatlantic dimensions of the American Anti-Imperialist Movement, 1899-1909., Feng, Yongping, The Peaceful Transition of Power from the UK to the US., Faunce, Rev. Perspectives . Mother countries would often build schools, railroads, and improved communication, along with new medicines and treatments. The caption reads: The Stranger: How long have you been civilized? TexasandU.S.S. A Rival Who Has Come to Stay. In May 1900, for example, artist William Bengough scathingly debunked a speech by President McKinleyonce again justifying the U.S. actions in taking of the Philippines by forceby depicting him as a parson standing on the face of a dead Filipino. Vaughan, Christopher. It allows prisoners to enjoy the view from the outside and have the illusion of freedom (Official Report to the War Office. In reality, it was just a cover-up to seek profits in these countries such as seen in the Hawaiian native on top of Uncle Sam's . The noble rhetoric that buttressed overseas expansion, as Twain presented it, was largely for Home Consumption, and stood in sharp contrast to the Actual Thing that the Customer Sitting in Darkness buys with his blood and tears and land and liberty. Where the Philippine temptation in particular was concerned, he cited press reports of atrocities by American troops. Initially, the camps were conceived as shelters for women and children war refugees. The cartoonist targets capitalists as the true power behind the policies and practices in the Pacific, with a portrait of businessman Marcus Hannaa dollar sign elongating his earthat dwarfs a portrait of President William McKinley. The world view that Rudyard Kipling and other proponents of colonialism believed in was one in which the white man was the guardian and protector of the planet and its people. 62, Issue 4,pp. The caption reads Think It Overa phrase that also appeared later in Mark Twains To the Person Sitting in Darkness essay. How such uncivilized behavior fit the rhetoric of the civilizing mission is the subject of theLifecartoon, A Red-Letter Day. Against a backdrop of distant flames, a Filipino mansympathetically drawn as tall, handsome, and heroic in contrast to the usual caricature of a tiny, expressionless savage in a grass skirtis questioned by a clergyman. Having defeated China in 189495, Japan is presented by Columbia (the U.S.) to her closest ally, Britannia (Great Britain). The caption at their feet exclaims United We Stand for Civilization and Peace!, United We Stand for Civilization and Peace! Louis Dalrymple,Puck, June 8, 1898. Around 1904 or 1905in another impassioned response to the American war in the Philippines (which officially ended in 1902 but in practice dragged on for many years thereafter)Twain penned a short essay titled The War Prayer. The essay is now regarded as an exemplary indictment of blind patriotism coupled with religious fanaticism. (The artist signed his name on the grave on the lower right.). The Source:Library of Congress. Most viewers will probably agree that there is nothing really comparable in the contemporary world of political cartooning to the drafting skill and flamboyance of these single-panel graphics, which appeared in such popular periodicals as Puck and Judge. [p. 199], The Way We Get the War News. In Pucks October 19, 1898 cover, Civilization holds China by his queue, labeled Worn Out Traditions, ready to cut it off with the shears of 19th Century Progress. The helpless mandarin tries to run away. These more critical graphics did not exist in a vacuum. The large Map of the United States and Neighboring Countries is dotted with U.S. flags marking newly-acquired territories. The white mans burden was an example of a justified imperialism argument to liberate the countries that lagged in economic, social, and political development in the 19 th century. Business and government colluded with the military in silencing press coverage of the poor conditions suffered by American soldiers, including scandals around tainted supplies, and the grim realities of the Philippine-American War itselfcensorship that foreshadowed the broader excising of the unpleasant war from national memory. Generic names on the gravestones are coupled with places of origin, including England, Scotland, Ireland, New Zealand, Canada, Australia, Gibraltar, India, Ceylon, and Egypt, indicating the diversity of those recruited to fight and die for the British Empire. In an 1898 two-page spread inPuck, female symbols of the two nations, Columbia and Britannia, meet as mother and daughter to celebrate their reunion After Many Years. Wearing archaic breastplates and helmets, with trident and sword, these outsized, archetypal crusaders helm modern warships. History in Three Keys: The Boxers as Event, Experience, and Myth(New York: Columbia University Press, 1997). This French cartoon eschews the romantic presentation in the preceding Puckgraphic and casts a far more cynical eye on Anglo-American expansion as fundamentally a matter of conquest. [Read Online]. The sign on the shores of England reads, John Bull The old reliable ship builder since 1861. western leaders perspective on the white man's burden. The artist George Benjamin Luts offered an exceptionally scathing rendering of the linkage of conquest, commerce, and censorship in an 1899 cartoon titled The Way We Get the War News: The Manila Correspondent and the McKinley Censorship. Published in a short-lived radical periodical,The Verdict, the cartoon shows a war correspondent in chains, writing his story under the direction of military brass. Source:Bibliothque nationale de France. The white man's burden poem was written by Rudyard Kipling. Two years ago the main street of Manila did not possess a single saloon. On the left, Minerva, goddess of wisdom and Western civilization, witnesses the debut. Priests Horribly Tortured. Revell, 1904). The Manila Correspondent and the McKinley Censorship. George Benjamin Luts,The Verdict, August 21, 1899. Source:Library of Congress, This rueful cartoon places Confucius and Jesus side-by-side and laments the failure of all parties to practice what they preach. Because those in Asia, Africa, and parts of the Americas lived different lives, Europeans felt that it was their duty to civilize them into western culture and society. Regarding the Philippines in particular, he continues: without any desire or design on our part, the war has brought us new duties and responsibilities which we must meet and discharge as becomes a great nation on whose growth and career from the beginning the ruler of nations has plainly written the high command and pledge of civilization. (doi:10.1093/cjip/pol005), Faunce, Rev. Twain went along, partly out of concern for his family, and The War Prayer was not published until 1916, six years after his death. The Native: Ever since my home was burned to the ground and my wife and children shot.. 301-314 (2010). Despite several victories in the battle for Tianjin, chaotic Chinese forces melted away before the Allied advance. Heine provided Simplicissimus with what has become a justly famous image: an armed knight, representing the West, pours a torrent of blood over Asia, while his sword drips blood on Africa. Jones, Toby Craig. The Origins of the Boxer War: A Multinational Study(London, New York: RoutledgeCurzon, 2003). 4, pp. One victim of the UK Blair torture regime Fatima Boudchar was actually pregnant when kidnapped along with her husband for rendition. Transatlantic dimensions of the American Anti-Imperialist Movement, 1899-1909.Journal of Transatlantic Studies. At the same time, the distinction the artist draws between Britains burden and Americas is striking. An exclamation point was added to the phrase, The White (!) Few new vessels were commissioned until the 1880s when the first battleships were built,U.S.S. A mound of scribbled papers from an overflowing wastebasket testifies to the coercion exerted upon him to induce cooperation. Source:Library of Congress. To maintain its position in the international balance of power, Britain needed allies. Elle permet aux prisonniers de jouir de la vue du dehors et davoir ainsi lillusion de la libert (Rapport officiel au War Office. This ca. It was the anti-imperialist cartoonists, however, who most starkly posed the question: who is the real barbarian? Some of the poorest provinces in the north were further stressed by a destructive combination of flooding and prolonged drought. Tan, Chester C.The Boxer Catastrophe. A chained War Correspondent is forced to rewrite his reports under the direction of Major General Elwell Otis during the Philippine-American War. 8, No. At the same time, however, the suppression of The War Prayer helps highlight the courage and critical edge that many political cartoonists brought to the very same subject of spreading death and destruction in the name of civilization and progress. In the background, the artist placed a large portrait of a large man, Marcus Hanna, next to a miniature of President William McKinley to show their relative influence on policy. By not waiting for their consent she has greatly advanced the worlds civilization. In the United States, the most famous counter-voice to Kipling and his white mans burden rhetoric was the writer Mark Twain. gma news pagasa weather update today 2021. The White (!) The caption, titled The First Duty, carries this subtitle: Civilization (to China)That dragon must be killed before our troubles can be adjusted. Imperial and Anti-Imperial Constructions of Civilisation: Engagements with Pre-Modern Pasts., Ricard, Serge. The image argues that a crisis point has been reached and the caption states, Some One Must Back Up., Left:Auto-Truck of Civilization and Trade,Progress,Force if Necessary,Cotton Dry Goods Education, Right:Boxer,400 Million Barbarians,China, Civilization and barbarism meet as the headlight of Uncle Sams gun-mounted Auto-Truck of Civilization and Trade shines the light of Progress on China. Published during the Boxer uprisings against Westerners and Christians, the cartoon portrays China as a frenzied dragon under the control of a Boxer gripping a bloody sword and banner reading 400 Million Barbarians. In the balance of power between technological progress and primitive barbarians, the cartoon makes clear who must back up.. Uneasiness over the idea of using force to govern a country was overcome by tracing the issue of consent back through recent history. Source:Library of Congress. (doi:10.1080/14650040802275644). The caption again ironically quotes an Official Report to the War Office that praises the British soldiers bravery in the face of a fierce enemy, in this case women and children: The humanity of our soldiers is admirable and does not tire despite the ferocity of Boers., Vers le Camp de Reconcentration (To the Concentration Camp). Klein, Thoralf. In the September 28, 1901 issue, artist Jean Veber excoriated the shameful subject of the concentration camps British forces used to weaken Boer resistance in the Anglo-Boer War of 18991902. Jesus, In an 1899 cartoon, Ren Georges Hermann-Paul attacked the hypocrisy of spreading civilization by force by juxtaposing the words Barbarie and Civilisation beneath Chinese and French combatants who alternate as victor and victim. At the same time, Britain was fighting the Anglo-Boer War in South Africa. Lifes satire of the white mans burden mystique offers a procession of the supporters of the new imperialism beginning with missionaries and ending with the traveling salesman. The influx of cheap Western goods eroded generations-long trading patterns, while telegraph and railroad lines were constructed in violation of superstitions, eliciting deep resentment among Chinese. This early outburst of what we refer to today as clash-of-civilizations thinking did not go unchallenged, however. Europeans had a duty to introduce the benefits of their civilization to non-European peoples is the statement which best expresses the Western perspective regarding Rudyard Kipling's "white Source:Bibliothque nationale de France, In this cartoon from the French special issue on concentration camps in the Boer War, a gaunt Britannia is the only living creature in a vast graveyard for dead British soldiers. Many peasants vaguely suspected of being Boxers were executed. This special issue illustrated by Thophile Steinlen comprises a particularly gruesome mural depicting the bloodshed of contemporary colonial wars in Turkey, China, and Africa. He says, Take up the White Mans burden, Send forth the best ye breed This special issue ofLAssiette au Beurredrew particular attention to the brutal tactics adopted by the British in the Boer War, including herding the families of the Boer opponent into concentration camps. To the Person Sitting in Darkness.. The larger objective, to gain control of the Boer territories, was part of Britains colonial scheme for Cape to Cairo hegemony in Africa. Britain is digesting China, Egypt, Australia, Africa, Canada, and India. Moral clarity aside, the parallel between America's pursuit of manifest destiny a century ago and its new global sense of mission has a lot to teach us. Our Christmas Tree. Udo Keppler,Puck, December 27, 1899. Historical perspective. Contemporary conflicts are spelled out over dark clouds. The racism and contempt for non-Western others that undergirds Kiplings famous poemand the civilizing mission in generalis unmistakable here. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like White Man's Burden, East India Company, Opium War and more. An exceptionally vivid cartoon version of Kiplings message titled The White Mans Burden (Apologies to Rudyard Kipling) was published inJudgeon April 1, 1899. Vignette-style graphics placed an array of smaller scenes around the central image. The 1901 date indicates that the specific reference is to Allied reprisals against Chinese civilians following the Boxer Uprising. An elaboratePuckgraphic from early in 1899 called School Begins incorporates all the players in a classroom scene to illustrate the legitimacy of governing without consent. In the centerfold of the August 16, 1899 issue of Puck, the not-so-cynical Keppler extended his feminization of global power politics to other great nations including a new arrival on the scene: Japan. As the disturbance escalated, so did news coverage around the world. School Begins. Uncle Sam (to his new class in Civilization): Now, children, youve got to learn these lessons whether you want to or not! However, these came at a huge price for the people of these regions. Fears that China would descend into chaos and xenophobia justified intervention to safeguard the spread of modernity, civilization, and trade. The rays of the sun shine over Uncle Sam and John Bull, who clasp hands in a renewed Anglo-American alliance of Kindred Interests rooted in the English Tongue. Warships on the horizon ground their mission in naval power. Source:The Ohio State University Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum. Close behind them lie corpses from the Franco-Prussian War, Russia and Turkey, Napoleon and Austria. Far off in the distance, with labels reading Roman Wars and Alexandria, the artists carries his viewers back to ancient times, when the civilization myth first emerged to mask the brutal realities of politically-motivated conflicts. Source:Bibliothque nationale de France, British soldiers laugh at the spectacle of Boer prisoners of war being shocked by an electric fence. When applied to people and cultures, the survival of the fittest doctrine gave wealthy, technologically-advanced countries not only the right to dominate backward nations, but an imperative and duty to bring them into the modern world. On the magazines cover for August 8, 1900, the familiar feminized and godlike personification of the West points at a slavering dragon, labeled Boxer, crawling over the wall of the capital city. Expansionism promulgated under the banner of civilization could not escape being carried out in global military campaigns, referred to as the savage wars of peace in the third stanza: Such avowed paternalism towards other cultures recast the invasion of their lands as altruistic service to humankind. (DOI:10.1080/14664658.2011.559749), Twain, Mark. Accusations of atrocities against civilians on the ten-day march to Beijing were made in first-hand accounts of the mission. Source: Beinecke Rare Books & Manuscripts, Yale University, A white, feminine personification of Civilization (written on her cloak) radiates light over the aged figure of China (written on his hem) running away and shielding himself with a parasol. The U.S. follows Britains imperial lead carrying people from Barbarism at the base of the hill to Civilization at its summit. It was written in support of Americas attempt to annex the Philippines. Although protested by some commanders, no single approach prevailed among these competitive armies thrown together in a loose coalition. ), yesterday we took important commandos. A more earthly approach is taken in the graphic Some One Must Back Up that heads this essay. The Centre for Research on Globalization will not be responsible for any inaccurate or incorrect statement in this article. English Lessons: The Pedagogy of Imperialism in Nineteenth-Century China(Durham: Duke University Press, 2003). Invading foreign lands was a relatively new experience for the U.S. Case Study: The Boxer WarThe Boxer Uprising.Online Encyclopediaof Mass Violence(July 23, 2008). In addition, the U.S. ignored human rights violations in the use of concentration camps. BritanniaDaughter! This idea is presented in a poetic way, by a British poet, Rudyard Kipling, in his poem The white mans burden written in 1898. '. Lifepublished many graphics that showed the humanitarian costs inflicted by war and political aggressiondespoliation, looting, concentration camps, torture, and genocideoften awkwardly interspersed amongst humorous sketches and domestic scenes. Cullinane, M. Patrick. Literature follows, holding the text of Kiplings poem, The White Mans Burden. Music plays an organ labeled Two Step SymphonyDollar Mark Forever. Behind Music comes Sculpture, holding up a monument to a war hero. Auto-Truck of Civilization and Trade: the Asia Market. Mans Burden William H. Walker, cover illustration,Life, March 16, 1899. The phrase White Mans Burden caught on with many imperialists to justify the policy as noble. The belief in racial/cultural superiority that fueled the British empire embraced the U.S. in Anglo-Saxonism based on common heritage and language. The satirical weekly,Simplicissimus, flourished from 1896 to 1967 with a hiatus from 1944 to 1954. Philippines, Hawaii, Cuba, Porto Rico. A Native American reads a book upside down and a prospective Chinese pupil stands in the doorway. (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1938). Kipling offered moral justification for the bloody war the U.S. was fighting to suppress the independent Philippine regime following Spanish rule. Along with his burden of steel, trains, sewing machines, and other industrial goods, Uncle Sam carries a book titled Education, Religion in a nod to the rhetoric of moral uplift that accompanied the commercial goals of the civilizing mission. No blow has been struck except for liberty and humanity, and none will be., Is this Imperialism? The turn of the century also witnessed emergence of articulate anti-imperialist voices worldwideand this movement had its own powerful wing of incisive graphic artists. Were we to transport an army more than half way around the earth merely to listen to peace propositions? (This coincided with the annexation of Hawaii as a U.S. territory in congressional votes in June and July of the same year.) The title of the cartoon calls attention to the barbarous uses of much modern technology and so-called progress., les prisonniers bors ont t runis en de grands enclos o depuis 18 mois ils trouvent le repos et le calme. For example, the light of civilization literally illuminated vicious, helpless, or clueless barbarians. Vol 172 (February 1901). Uncle Sam, armed and dangerous, cocks an eyebrow as he displays his handiwork: countless dead Filipino soldiers laid out in rows. Vultures hover above the procession, and the artifacts of past civilization are trampled underfoot at the rear. Model students Hawaii and Porto Rico appear as docile girls learning their lessons. Titled Dream of the Empress of China, the dream is an obvious nightmare, as the sardonic sub-caption makes clear. Source:Library of Congress, Left: John Bull gapes at a new American steamer. Colonial success is equated with chivalry and invincibility.. Kipling was a white supremascist and wrote The White Mans Burden urging the United States to take up the burden of civilizing savage peoples alongside other European powers. Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey (2014). U.S. regiments were transported from the Philippines to join the Allied force. He is greeted with open arms by a mandarin and Wanted signs articulating prodigious opportunities for business. It was written in support of Americas attempt to annex the Philippines. Ugly and shocking scenes of violence in 19th-century American life are ironically captioned as refined and elegant to challenge the self-image of a nation contributing cash to save the heathen of foreign lands while ignoring its own barbarity. In his 1898 notes for the Treaty of Pariswhich ended the Spanish-American War with Spain surrendering Cuba and ceding territories including Puerto Rico, Guam, and the PhilippinesMcKinley made a prototypical statement of the civilizers responsibilities in the kind of rhetoric still used today: We took up arms only in obedience to the dictates of humanity and in the fulfillment of high public and moral obligations. Commercial interests not only drove U.S. policy in Asia, but also shaped public opinion about it. Although Wilhelm II was famous for introducing the concept of a yellow peril, Germanys major colonial possessions were in Africa. World powers competing for spheres of influence within her borders had grown ever bolder in their demands as the Qing rulers appeared increasingly weak. Allied troops departed Tianjin for Beijing on August 4. McKinley also mentions profit, free trade, and the open door in Asia: Incidental to our tenure in the Philippines is the commercial opportunity to which American statesmanship cannot be indifferent. ), In an image titled, Vers le Camp de Reconcentration (To the Concentration Camp), women and children are dragged off by British soldiers. Jean Veber,LAssiette au Beurre, September 28, 1901. Even the name of the poem is paternalistic in that he views The Great Rapprochement describes a shift in the relationship of the U.S. and Great Britain that, in the 1890s, moved from animosity and suspicion to friendship and cooperation. Turbo Tickets Edmonton, Articles W

2793c07b529eabdf9b08e24c8dc4a635